Sunday, October 09, 2005

When will someone say something?

From 1974-1976, Donald Rumsfeld, Dick Cheyney and Paul Wolfowitz were part of what was called Team B (ref). Their task was to make the Soviet Union into a fearful enemy that wanted us all dead. They built up a story (based on no facts) that the Soviet Union had weapons we could not detect. The CIA's comment on this is 'Team B is moving into a fantasy world'.

This is a mirror image of what was happening when we are told there is a global conspiracy of terror. It is a lie. Do not buy into it. Yes there are terrorists but, no, there is no global network organized against 'us' withsecret weapons we cannot see.

Now today, some 30 years later the leaders are refering to the past lie to give support for the new lie? When will someone in a position of power say something about this? What of all those senators and house speakers who sat through the hearing in 1975 listening to Rumsfeld contsruct a case based on nothing? I can accept that at the time they might have been scared but now with 30 years of hindsight and the fact that the events from 1975 are textbook history. Why doesn't anybody at least take Rumsfeld aside and tell him to cut it out?

Bush Likens War on Terror to Cold War, LA Times.

If you have not seen the Powers Of Nighmares, please do. You can download it for free here. Just read the first paragraph of the transcript below, I cannot have empathy for Rumsfeld, my conclusion is that he is (1) mentally deranged (2) an evil man (3) thinks he can shape the world into what he wants?

The following is taken from an unoficial transcript of the BBC special, The Power of Nightmares:

"The Soviet Union has been busy," Defense Secretary Rumsfeld explained to America in 1976. "They've been busy in terms of their level of effort; they've been busy in terms of the actual weapons they 've been producing; they've been busy in terms of expanding production rates; they've been busy in terms of expanding their institutional capability to produce additional weapons at additional rates; they've been busy in terms of expanding their capability to increasingly improve the sophistication of those weapons. Year after year after year, they've been demonstrating that they have steadiness of purpose. They're purposeful about what they're doing."

The CIA strongly disagreed, calling Rumsfeld's position a "complete fiction" and pointing out that the Soviet Union was disintegrating from within, could barely afford to feed their own people, and would collapse within a decade or two if simply left alone. But Rumsfeld and Cheney wanted Americans to believe there was something nefarious going on, something we should be very afraid of. To this end, they convinced President Ford to appoint a commission including their old friend Paul Wolfowitz to prove that the Soviets were up to no good.

According to Curtis' BBC documentary, Wolfowitz's group, known as "Team B," came to the conclusion that the Soviets had developed several terrifying new weapons of mass destruction, featuring a nuclear-armed submarine fleet that used a sonar system that didn't depend on sound and was, thus, undetectable with our current technology. The BBC's documentarians asked Dr. Anne Cahn of the U.S. Arms Control and Disarmament Agency during that time, her thoughts on Rumsfeld's, Cheney's, and Wolfowitz's 1976 story of the secret Soviet WMDs. Here's a clip from a transcript of that BBC documentary:

"Dr ANNE CAHN, Arms Control and Disarmament Agency, 1977-80: They couldn't say that the Soviets had acoustic means of picking up American submarines, because they couldn't find it. So they said, well maybe they have a non-acoustic means of making our submarine fleet vulnerable. But there was no evidence that they had a non-acoustic system. They're saying, 'we can't find evidence that they're doing it the way that everyone thinks they're doing it, so they must be doing it a different way. We don't know what that different way is, but they must be doing it.'

"INTERVIEWER (off-camera): Even though there was no evidence.

"CAHN: Even though there was no evidence.

"INTERVIEWER: So they're saying there, that the fact that the weapon doesn't exist.

"CAHN: Doesn't mean that it doesn't exist. It just means that we haven't found it."

The moderator of the BBC documentary then notes:

"What Team B accused the CIA of missing was a hidden and sinister reality in the Soviet Union. Not only were there many secret weapons the CIA hadn't found, but they were wrong about many of those they could observe, such as the Soviet air defenses. The CIA were convinced that these were in a state of collapse, reflecting the growing economic chaos in the Soviet Union. Team B said that this was actually a cunning deception by the Soviet régime. The air-defense system worked perfectly. But the only evidence they produced to prove this was the official Soviet training manual, which proudly asserted that their air-defense system was fully integrated and functioned flawlessly. The CIA accused Team B of moving into a fantasy world."

Nonetheless, as Melvin Goodman, head of the CIA's Office of Soviet Affairs, 1976-87, noted in the BBC documentary,

"Rumsfeld won that very intense, intense political battle that was waged in Washington in 1975 and 1976. Now, as part of that battle, Rumsfeld and others, people such as Paul Wolfowitz, wanted to get into the CIA. And their mission was to create a much more severe view of the Soviet Union, Soviet intentions, Soviet views about fighting and winning a nuclear war."

1 Comments:

At 12:43 PM, October 12, 2005, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bob,

After Bechtel Corp. screwed up the Big Dig, they're still repairing shoddy work!! Bechtel was given contracts by FEMA after Hurricane Katrina. It's painfully obvious these people have no shame.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home